Dog Harness and Leash : Which Is Right For Your Dog?

Dog Walkers | 0 comments

Are you unsure about which type of dog harness and leash is best for your furry friend? Look no further! In this article, we will explore the different options available and help you determine the perfect fit for your dog’s needs. Whether you have a small pup or a large, energetic dog, finding the right harness and leash is essential for their comfort and safety during walks and outdoor adventures. Join us as we break down the pros and cons of each choice, making your decision-making process a breeze. Get ready to take your dog for a stroll with confidence!



Table of Contents

Harness or Leash: Factors to Consider

Size and Strength

When choosing between a dog harness and leash, one important factor to consider is the size and strength of your dog. A smaller dog may do well with a simple leash, while a larger and stronger dog may require the added control and security provided by a dog harness. It’s essential to match the equipment to your dog’s physical attributes to ensure comfort and safety during walks.

Training and Behavior

Another factor to consider is your dog’s training and behavior. If your dog is well-trained and walks calmly on a leash, a traditional leash may be sufficient. However, if your dog tends to pull or exhibit behavior issues during walks, a dog harness may offer more control and help with training. Understanding your dog’s behavior and training needs will guide you in making the right choice.

Health Considerations

Your dog’s health should also be taken into account when deciding between a dog leash and harness. Dogs with respiratory issues, such as brachycephalic breeds (short-nosed dogs),may benefit from a harness that avoids putting pressure on their sensitive throat and neck areas. Additionally, dogs with neck or back injuries may find a harness more comfortable and supportive during walks. It’s always best to consult with your veterinarian for specific health considerations.

Activity Level

Consider your dog’s activity level when choosing between a harness and leash. If your dog is highly active and prone to pulling or lunging, a dog harness provides better control and prevents injuries. On the other hand, if your dog is generally well-behaved and walks calmly, a leash may be sufficient for your needs. It’s important to match the equipment to your dog’s energy level and behavior during walks.


Lastly, your budget is an important factor to consider when deciding between a harness and leash. While both options come in a range of prices, certain types of harnesses, such as those designed for specialized training or made from premium materials, may come with a higher price tag. It’s important to determine your budget beforehand and find a balance between quality and affordability that suits your needs.

Benefits of Dog Harness

Evenly Distributed Tension

One of the significant benefits of using a dog harness is that it evenly distributes tension across your dog’s body. Unlike a leash that attaches to a dog’s collar, a harness wraps around the chest or body, reducing the strain on your dog’s neck and throat. This even distribution of tension can help prevent injuries and discomfort during walks, particularly for dogs prone to pulling or lunging.

Added Control and Security

A dog harness offers additional control and security compared to a leash, especially for dogs that tend to pull or struggle during walks. The design and placement of a harness allow you to steer your dog and redirect their attention more effectively. This added control can enhance the safety of both your dog and others in the vicinity, providing a more pleasant and secure walking experience.

Protection for Neck and Throat

For dogs with certain health conditions or breeds with delicate necks and throats, a harness provides crucial protection. The pressure and strain from a traditional leash attached to a collar can potentially harm these sensitive areas. By using a harness, you can avoid putting unnecessary pressure on your dog’s neck and throat, ensuring their well-being during walks.

Reduced Risk of Escaping

If you have a dog that tends to be an escape artist or easily slips out of their collar, a dog harness can be a lifesaver. Harnesses are designed to wrap around your dog’s body, making it much more difficult for them to wriggle free. The secure fit and snug connection of a harness can significantly reduce the risk of your dog escaping during walks, providing peace of mind and preventing potential accidents or loss.

Ideal for Pullers and Brachycephalic Breeds

Dog harnesses are particularly beneficial for dogs that have a tendency to pull on the leash. The design of a harness allows you to have better control and redirect your dog’s attention when they pull or engage in undesirable behaviors. Additionally, brachycephalic breeds, like Bulldogs or Pugs, often have breathing difficulties and are prone to respiratory issues. A harness takes the pressure off their sensitive throat and helps prevent respiratory distress during walks.

Types of Dog Harness

Back-clip Harness

A back-clip harness is one of the most common types of dog harnesses and features a D-ring attachment on the back of the harness. This type of harness is easy to put on and take off and provides good control for dogs that don’t pull excessively. It’s suitable for dogs of all sizes and is a popular choice for everyday walks and leisurely outings.

Front-clip Harness

A front-clip harness, also known as a chest-clip harness, has a D-ring attachment located on the front of the harness, near the dog’s chest. This type of harness provides better control and prevents pulling by redirecting your dog’s forward motion. Front-clip harnesses are particularly useful for dogs that tend to pull or are undergoing leash training.

Dual-clip Harness

A dual-clip harness combines the benefits of both back-clip and front-clip harnesses. It features attachments on both the back and front of the harness, giving you the flexibility to use whichever clip suits your needs. This type of harness is ideal for training purposes, as you can gradually transition your dog’s behavior from pulling to walking calmly with the front clip.

Head Halter Harness

A head halter harness is designed similarly to a halter for horses and fits around your dog’s muzzle. This type of harness gives you control over your dog’s head movements and can be effective in managing pulling or lunging. It’s important to note that head halters should be used with caution and require proper introduction and training to ensure your dog’s comfort and safety.

No-pull Harness

As the name suggests, a no-pull harness is specifically designed to discourage pulling behavior. These harnesses often feature a front-clip attachment that redirects the dog’s forward motion and teaches them to walk beside you. No-pull harnesses are ideal for dogs that require additional training and control during walks.

Step-in Harness

A step-in harness is a simple and convenient option that is easy to put on and take off your dog. They typically feature two loops that your dog steps into, eliminating the need to go over the head or through leg openings. Step-in harnesses are suitable for dogs that don’t pull excessively and are a popular choice for small and medium-sized breeds.

Vest-style Harness

Vest-style harnesses are designed to provide maximum comfort and support for your dog. They often feature padded straps that distribute pressure evenly and prevent rubbing or chafing. Vest-style harnesses are suitable for dogs of all sizes and are an excellent choice for dogs with neck or back issues or those requiring additional support during walks.

Car Harness

A car harness is specifically designed to secure your dog safely while traveling in a vehicle. These harnesses typically attach to the car’s seatbelt system or latch anchors and prevent your dog from moving around or being thrown in the event of sudden stops or accidents. Car harnesses are essential for your dog’s safety during car rides and are a legal requirement in many areas.

Considerations for Choosing a Dog Harness

Dog’s Size and Body Shape

When choosing a dog harness, it’s important to consider your dog’s size and body shape. Different harnesses are designed to accommodate various sizes and body types, ensuring proper fit and comfort. Measure your dog’s chest girth and check the sizing guidelines provided by the manufacturer to select the appropriate harness size.

Purpose and Use

Consider the purpose and use of the harness when making your selection. If you’re looking for an everyday walking harness, a comfortable and easy-to-use option like a back-clip or step-in harness may be ideal. However, if you plan to use the harness for training purposes, a front-clip or no-pull harness may be better suited for your needs.

Level of Control Needed

Evaluate the level of control you require during walks. If your dog tends to pull or exhibits strong prey-drive, a harness with a front-clip or head halter harness may provide the control you need to manage their behavior effectively. Dogs that walk calmly on a leash may not need as much control and can be comfortable with a back-clip or step-in harness.

Training Requirements

Consider your dog’s training requirements when selecting a harness. Some harnesses, like front-clip or no-pull harnesses, can assist in leash training and behavior modification. If your dog needs extra help in learning to walk politely on a leash, these types of harnesses may be beneficial. Keep in mind that training should always involve positive reinforcement and patience.

Comfort and Fit

Ensuring the comfort and fit of the harness is essential for your dog’s well-being during walks. Look for harnesses with adjustable straps and padding to prevent rubbing or chafing. A properly fitting harness should allow your dog to move naturally without restricting their movement. Take accurate measurements and follow the manufacturer’s sizing recommendations to find the right fit for your dog.

Material and Durability

Consider the material and durability of the harness to make sure it can withstand your dog’s activities and last for a long time. High-quality materials, such as nylon or polyester webbing, are commonly used in harness construction. Look for reinforced stitching and sturdy hardware to ensure the harness can withstand pulling and everyday wear and tear.

Dog being walked wearing a harness and two dogs on the grass field.

This image is property of

Benefits of Dog Leash

Direct Control

One of the primary benefits of using a dog leash is the direct control it provides over your dog’s movements. Unlike a harness that distributes tension across the body, a leash attached to a collar allows you to guide and steer your dog in the desired direction. This direct control is essential for maintaining safety during walks and ensuring your dog stays close by your side.

Safety and Preventing Accidents

A dog leash is crucial for preventing accidents and ensuring your dog’s safety. It keeps your dog within a safe distance, especially in areas with traffic or potential hazards. A leash allows you to quickly react and prevent your dog from running off, chasing after something, or getting into dangerous situations. It provides peace of mind and keeps your dog protected during outdoor activities.

Facilitating Training

Using a leash is an effective training tool that facilitates obedience and leash manners. It allows you to establish boundaries, teach commands, and reinforce good behavior during walks. Leash training is essential for puppies or newly adopted dogs to learn proper leash etiquette and become well-behaved companions in various settings. A leash provides the control needed for effective training sessions.

Convenience for Daily Walks

A dog leash offers convenience for daily walks and outings. It provides a quick and easy way to have your dog by your side, allowing you to focus on enjoying your time together. Leashes come in various lengths, allowing you to tailor your walks to suit your dog’s exercise needs and explore different environments safely. With a leash, it’s easy to lead your dog through parks, neighborhoods, and other outdoor spaces.

Legal Requirements in Some Areas

In many areas, using a leash is a legal requirement. Municipalities often enforce leash laws to maintain community safety and prevent incidents involving dogs. It’s important to familiarize yourself with the leash regulations specific to your area and comply with them. Using a leash not only keeps you in accordance with local laws but also demonstrates responsible dog ownership.

Types of Dog Leashes

Standard Leash

A standard leash is a basic and straightforward option for dog walking. It typically consists of a sturdy nylon or leather strap with a handle on one end and a snap hook on the other end to attach to your dog’s collar. Standard leashes come in various lengths, allowing you to choose the most suitable option for your needs.

Retractable Leash

Retractable leashes have gained popularity for their convenience and flexibility. They feature a thin cord or tape that can be extended and retracted using a mechanism in the handle. Retractable leashes allow your dog more freedom to explore their surroundings while still providing the ability to reel them back in when necessary. They are particularly helpful for dogs that do well off-leash but require control in certain situations.

Adjustable Leash

An adjustable leash offers versatility in length and can be modified to various shorter lengths as needed. They typically have several D-ring attachments along the leash, allowing you to adjust the length according to your preference or specific situations. Adjustable leashes are convenient for casual walks or when you need your dog to stay close by your side.

Chain Leash

Chain leashes are made of metal links and provide durability and strength. They are suitable for dogs that are strong pullers or have a tendency to chew through or damage other types of leashes. Chain leashes offer more control and can withstand the pressure and force exerted by stronger dogs. However, it’s important to ensure that the chain section does not cause discomfort or harm to your dog.

Hands-Free Leash

Hands-free leashes are designed for active dog owners who want to keep their hands free during walks, runs, or other activities. They typically include a waist belt or shoulder strap that attaches to the leash, allowing you to secure your dog while maintaining mobility. Hands-free leashes are convenient for jogging, hiking, or multitasking during walks.

Bungee Leash

A bungee leash features a flexible and stretchy section that absorbs shock and reduces strain on both you and your dog. This type of leash is particularly useful for dogs that tend to pull suddenly or make quick movements during walks. The bungee element provides a gentle give and helps prevent jolting or discomfort when your dog reaches the end of the leash.

Martingale Leash

Martingale leashes, also known as limited-slip leashes, are designed to prevent dogs from slipping out of their collars. They consist of a section of looped material or chain that tightens when tension is applied, preventing the collar from slipping over the dog’s head. Martingale leashes are often used in training or with dogs that have a tendency to escape or back out of their collars.

dog harness and leash which is right for your dog 1

This image is property of

Considerations for Choosing a Dog Leash

Leash Length

Consider the appropriate leash length for your needs and your dog’s behavior. Shorter leashes, such as standard or adjustable leashes, offer more control and are suitable for walks in crowded or high-traffic areas. Retractable leashes are ideal for dogs that do well off-leash but need control in certain situations. Choose a leash length that allows your dog to have ample freedom while maintaining safety and convenience.

Material and Durability

The material and durability of a leash are crucial factors in selecting the right one for your dog. Nylon and leather are commonly used materials for leashes, each with its own benefits. Nylon leashes are lightweight, affordable, and easy to clean, making them suitable for most dog owners. Leather leashes are more durable and provide a classic and stylish look, although they require more care and maintenance.

Handle Comfort

Consider the comfort of the leash handle for comfortable and enjoyable walks. The handle should be ergonomic, providing a secure and comfortable grip that minimizes strain on your hand and wrist. Look for leashes with padded or cushioned handles that prevent chafing or discomfort, particularly during longer walks or activities.

Control Features

Evaluate the control features offered by the leash to match your specific needs. Some leashes have additional control options, such as multiple attachment points, additional handles, or built-in traffic handles. These features provide extra control in situations that require closer proximity or restraint of your dog. Consider the level of control necessary for your walks and activities.

Training Compatibility

If you’re using a leash for training purposes, ensure that it is compatible with your training methods. Certain leashes, like martingale or slip leads, are commonly used in training settings to discourage pulling or improve leash manners. It’s important to familiarize yourself with the specific training techniques and consult with a professional trainer if needed.

Visibility and Reflectivity

In low-light conditions or during night time walks, visibility and reflectivity are crucial for safety. Look for leashes with reflective strips or materials that increase visibility and make you and your dog more visible to drivers or pedestrians. Reflective leashes help prevent accidents and ensure that you and your dog are easily seen during walks in dimly lit areas.

Harness vs. Leash: Which to Choose?

Combining Harness and Leash

Choosing between a harness and leash doesn’t necessarily have to be an either-or decision. In fact, a combination of both can offer the best of both worlds. By using a harness in conjunction with a leash, you can provide added control and security during walks. The harness distributes tension evenly and helps prevent injuries, while the leash allows for direct control and training.

Harness for Everyday Walks

If your dog is well-behaved and walks calmly on a leash, a traditional leash may suffice for everyday walks. However, if your dog tends to pull, lunge, or exhibit behavior issues, a harness may be a better option. A harness provides additional control and prevents strain on your dog’s neck, making it more comfortable for them during walks. Choose a harness that suits your dog’s size, activity level, and behavior.

Leash for Training Purposes

When it comes to training, a leash is an essential tool for teaching and reinforcing good leash manners. A leash allows you to maintain direct control, redirect your dog’s attention, and establish boundaries. If your dog requires training to walk politely on a leash, a leash, in combination with proper positive reinforcement methods, can help you achieve your training goals effectively.

Considerations for Specific Dog Breeds

Certain dog breeds may benefit more from either a harness or leash based on their specific characteristics. Brachycephalic breeds with respiratory issues or dogs with neck or back injuries may find a harness more comfortable and supportive. Dogs that tend to pull or have a high prey drive may require a harness to curb their behavior effectively. Consider your dog’s breed and individual needs when making your choice.

Personal Preference and Comfort

Ultimately, your personal preference and your dog’s comfort should play a significant role in determining whether a harness or leash is the right choice. Experiment with both options and observe your dog’s behavior and response. Choose the equipment that provides the most comfort, control, and enjoyment for both you and your dog during walks.

dog harness


This image is property of


Top Brands and Products for Dog Harness and Leash

Ruffwear Front Range Harness

The Ruffwear Front Range Harness is a popular choice among dog owners for its durability and comfort. It features two attachment points, a back-clip for everyday walks and a reinforced front-clip for training purposes. The harness is adjustable and has padded straps to prevent chafing. It comes in various sizes and vibrant colors, making it both functional and stylish.

Kurgo Journey Dog Harness

The Kurgo Journey Dog Harness is designed with durability and versatility in mind. It has a back-clip attachment for regular walks and a front-clip option for training or added control. The harness features a padded chest and back, as well as adjustable straps for a secure and comfortable fit. It also includes a handle on the back for convenient lifting or assistance.

EzyDog Chest Plate Harness

The EzyDog Chest Plate Harness offers comfort and security with its ergonomic design. It has a chest plate that distributes pressure evenly and prevents strain on your dog’s neck and back. The harness is easy to put on and take off, with adjustable straps for a custom fit. It also has a sturdy back handle for quick control or assistance if needed.

PetSafe Gentle Leader Headcollar

For dogs that require additional control and prevent pulling, the PetSafe Gentle Leader Headcollar is an effective choice. It fits around your dog’s muzzle and provides gentle pressure to redirect their attention and discourage pulling. The headcollar is adjustable and features a padded nose loop for comfort. It offers an alternative to traditional harnesses and can be a valuable training tool.

Max and Neo Double Handle Traffic Leash

The Max and Neo Double Handle Traffic Leash is a versatile and convenient leash option. It features two handles, one at the end of the leash and one closer to the attachment point, allowing for better control in various situations. The leash is made of durable nylon and has reflective stitching for increased visibility. Each purchase also helps support dog rescues and organizations.

Flexi New Comfort Retractable Dog Leash

The Flexi New Comfort Retractable Dog Leash combines convenience and flexibility. It features a retractable cord that extends and retracts smoothly, allowing your dog more freedom to explore while providing control when needed. The leash has a soft-grip handle and a braking system for added safety. Various sizes are available to accommodate different dog weights and strengths.

Mighty Paw Hands-Free Bungee Leash

The Mighty Paw Hands-Free Bungee Leash is perfect for active dog owners who want to keep their hands free during walks or runs. It attaches around your waist and features a bungee section that absorbs shock and reduces strain on you and your dog. The leash has a reflective stitching for enhanced visibility and includes a storage pouch for essentials, such as keys or waste bags.

Blue-9 Pet Products Balance Harness

The Blue-9 Pet Products Balance Harness is designed for optimal comfort and support. It has adjustable straps and a dual-clip for versatility in training and everyday walks. The harness features a foam-padded chest plate to distribute pressure evenly, ensuring your dog’s comfort during walks. It also has a back handle for quick control or assistance.

Dog Harness and Leash: Conclusion

When choosing between a dog harness and leash, it’s important to consider factors such as your dog’s size, behavior, health, activity level, and your budget. Both options offer unique benefits and cater to different needs. A dog harness evenly distributes tension, provides added control and security, protects the neck and throat, and reduces the risk of escaping. On the other hand, a dog leash offers direct control, ensures safety, helps with training, provides convenience for daily walks, and fulfills legal requirements in some areas.

The types of dog harnesses include back-clip, front-clip, dual-clip, head halter, no-pull, step-in, vest-style, and car harnesses. Leash options include standard, retractable, adjustable, chain, hands-free, bungee, and martingale leashes. When choosing a dog harness or leash, consider factors such as your dog’s size and body shape, the purpose and use, the level of control needed, training requirements, comfort and fit, material and durability.

Ultimately, the choice between a dog harness and leash depends on personal preference, your dog’s comfort, and your specific needs. Combining a harness and leash can offer the best of both worlds, using a harness for everyday walks and a leash for training purposes. Specific dog breeds may benefit more from either a harness or leash based on their characteristics. It’s important to select a reputable brand and consider top products such as the Ruffwear Front Range Harness, Kurgo Journey Dog Harness, EzyDog Chest Plate Harness, PetSafe Gentle Leader Headcollar, Max and Neo Double Handle Traffic Leash, Flexi New Comfort Retractable Dog Leash, Mighty Paw Hands-Free Bungee Leash, and Blue-9 Pet Products Balance Harness. Whether you choose a harness, leash, or a combination of both, prioritize your dog’s comfort, safety, and enjoyment during walks.





amazon narrow banner